🔗 Share this article

Deep-rooted failures that resulted in the breakdown of a China spy case might be replicated absent major overhauls, a committee of Members of Parliament has alerted.

Findings Identifies "Disorderly" Administration

A report by the Cross-party committee on the National Security Strategy declared "chaotic" administration caused authorities withdrawing allegations against Christopher Cash and Chris Berry, who were charged with transferring classified information to a China-based intelligence agent.

Both men maintain their innocence.

"Mishandling analogous later prosecutions will 'corrode public confidence'," cautioned chairman Matt Western.

Trial Failure and Controversy

Christopher Cash, a ex- researcher for MPs, and China-based academic Mr Berry, were both charged under the secrecy legislation in 2024.

He served two prominent MPs critical of China, the MP, then head of the Foreign Affairs Committee, and the MP, who subsequently held the identical role.

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) stated the prosecution fell apart after a senior government official, the deputy national security adviser (DNSA), refused to label China an "adversarial power" at the point of the alleged crimes.

However, the parliamentary committee stated they were "taken aback" by the prosecution's conclusion, implying it could have been "left to the court".

Key Points of the Report

The committee concluded there was no "concerted senior effort" to sabotage or impede the case.

Conversely, it was beset by "chaotic" handling and "uncertainty and misaligned expectations".

• Dialogue between the CPS and Whitehall were "inadequate".
• An protracted delay in acquiring a second account remains a mystery.
• The committee also disputed the government's contention that comparable prosecutions in the coming years under the recent law would not fail.

"We urge the administration to refrain from characterising the failure of this prosecution as a one-off oddity generated solely by archaic laws," the findings said.

Calls for Change

The committee calls for the government to consider introducing wide-ranging reforms within six months to avert a recurrence.

1. The position and accountability of the deputy national security adviser (DNSA) — which had been left "cut off and unsupported" — must be promptly examined and overhauled.
2. Communications between the prosecution service and the executive must also be "examined and enhanced at speed".
3. In subsequent prosecutions, every spy matter must hold a official briefing within a month of charge to spot flaws in the evidence early.
4. Greater "clear definition" must be given on whether government personnel are giving policy input or testimony.

The Labour MP said: "Given that the international security environment deteriorates, delicate state security trials will arise more frequently.

"Ministers must prove the public that it is confident in facing down adversaries when necessary: not doing so to do so will erode the public's confidence in our democracy."